SFWritersU

Welcome! Log in or Sign Up Now!

Discussions Craft Grammer --bleh-- procrastination

Grammer --bleh-- procrastination

Subscribe to Grammer --bleh-- procrastination 6 Posts, 5 voices , Tags : grammer English usage proper style strunck and white procrastination

Reply
 

Anna_headshot_medium Annasea 6 Posts

Now tell me, is it possible for this phrase, found in a glossy magazine, to be grammatically correct?:

 

"...he says one day a few months ago..."

 

doesn't says imply current, now, present? so how can anyone says months ago? Or am I overthinking this? I tend to do that.

 

Yeah, probly I'm overthinking it.

 

Sigh.

 

No wonder I can't get to the front door washed and dressed, cats fed on a given morning, let alone have a book ready for submission by Jan 5 contest.

 

o halp me

 
Chin_in_hand_black_and_white_medium amyjarecki 6 Posts

You are right! He said one day (comma) a few months ago...Actuall the whole statement is bad, and does not need the "one day". It should probably read, ..he said a few months ago...

 
Anna_headshot_medium Annasea 6 Posts

Well, it's an article about the mob, so if you want to correct him, go ahead... as for me, I like breathing too much to make a fuss LOL

 
Mephistopheles_medium SmallFish 1 Post

In context is could be correct. If the article is written in present tense, the subject of the article could be speaking in the present tense about something that occurred in the past.

 
Ari-with-book_medium robertsloan2 14 Posts

To me it just reads like dialogue. It's a typical speaking construction, right or wrong. I think it's okay to let characters violate grammar in dialogue as long as it's still intelligible. It tells me a lot about the speaker - including that he or she likes to talk and hear his or her own voice!

 
Img_0990_medium dhertzog 3 Posts

It reads like dialog to me, as well, with colloquial undertones...kind of a Jersey, "'[Joey,]' he says[to me]."   

Log in to reply to this topic

Discussions Craft Grammer --bleh-- procrastination

A Project of San Francisco Writers Conference